Catan HD Reviews

Sound doesn’t work

rtedfcvgty

There is a glitch where the sound doesn’t play on iOS

There are so many inconsiderate leavers when playing online. There absolutely needs to be a system implemented where you can see, next to the avatar on someone, their “sportsmanship rank” or something along those lines, which indicates how often they just leave matches after the initial settlement placements. Not the app’s problem, but it’s very frustrating and people need to be held accountable, suspended or banned if they do this over 50 percent of the time. Online is unplayable most of the time because of this, but this solution above would likely fix it. Also, when someone leaves a game and then rejoins, there is a frustrating glitch where you press the ready button and then it kind of “grays out” and you can’t press it again and confirm you are ready so there’s nothing you can do at that point because the button just stops working. This version if much more visually pleasing than the other one, and if you fixed these issues it would be the better app.

AI use of Resource Monopoly card ruins game

rpsozo

The AI players always seem to each get 4 or 5 resource monopoly cards whereas I get it maybe once per 3 whole games. It’s clearly slanted toward the AI players to get that card which just ruins the enjoyment of the game. And when they play it most of the time it gets a lot of resources from everyone as if it knows what each player has. It never gets zero. I have gotten zero resources several times playing the card. Just get rid of the card if you can’t give it out fairly to all players.

Wanted to like it

Conn-

Glitches make it nearly unplayable

Does’t work, defect when move the robber

Dabuff

I want my money back. Anytime you move the robber the control panel disappears so you can’t continue. Waste of money.

Terrible glitch

luciasalinasa

When I use the knight the side toolbar disappears so I have to restart the app. Terrible.

Abandoned???

PollyTreasures

I think this app has been abandoned. Ive been experiencing fatal error for months. I’ve deleted the app and later reinstalled but I’m now abandoning it just like the developers apparently have. It was fun while it worked, though.

Are the Dice Random ?

RB in SB

In there FAQ they claim the dice are random. As many reviewers have noted, the AI seems to get amazingly lucky. After playing hundreds of time, I think the dice are random. HOWEVER, it appears that the AI players have an edge in knowing what those random numbers will be. I can’t tell you how many times AI puts the robber on the number next rolled by the dice. What are the odds that it puts the robber on 11, just before I roll 11 twice in a row. Happens virtually every time the AI moves the robber. Just because they claim the rolls are random, it doesn’t mean the AI doesn’t know what those rolls are. The game should be “fair.” It isn’t at the moment.

Bugs

chwabe

All worked well until I bought Seafarers and Cities and Knights. Now has bugs in basic game when playing online. Disappointing.