Catan HD Reviews

Great fun

Houston Snipe

I've played dozens and dozens of hours of this game. I do experience the cards disappearing bug, but only during long gameplay and exiting and coming back fixes it. It's possible that the dice are rigged when you have lots of resources, but I've learned to use resources instead of hoarding them. Stack 5 setting on the dice prevents this anyway. I just wish there were more C&K scenarios. And if you can't beat the computer, guess what? You aren't very good at the game yet. Sure you'll get unlucky some games, but that uncertainty keeps it fun.

Like It!

Sara Frisbee

I really like this app and haven’t had any issues with it! Super addictive, especially since I’m trying to increase my skill level for playing the physical board game.

Bad AI

Dm@)$&(&'

Had 10 resources at end of turn, within two rounds between robber thrown once and each comp player playing seeming unlimited knight cards had 0 resources left. Had city and village on 6 wood and 2:1 wood trade. 10 rounds (30 rolls) no 6s. Robber moved to my wood and next 4/6 rolls were wood.

Rigged

Gbaby2

Newer updates have caused the game to be less random. If you have over 7 resources, someone will roll a 7 almost every time causing you to be robbed. If you are in the lead the computer players always put the robber on you.

Flawed but I like it.

Apple-Picker

I enjoy playing this solo, on the training during my commute. I see a lot of people complain about the dice generation. I haven’t been paying enough attention to notice, but I always set the setting to you the one that selects from all the possible .combinations

Freezes constantly

Adgdhegg5633

The game will often randomly stop responding after an action.

Hilariously can’t log in

Radikal rad

I’ve been trying to register an account for 45 minutes, and it just keeps telling me that “your email or password is already in use”. At one point I finally got it to work and it said a confirmation email was sent, but I never got the email, so I tried to log in, but instead of logging me in, it changed the language to German.

Love the board game...

Arrrrrrrrrrr99

But in this app, the dice are rigged. The dice rolls are statistically impossible. It all starts out normal until you start winning. Suddenly the dice only roll numbers you do not have but the AI does. This happens roll after roll until the AI catches up or wins. It is so glaring the game is not remotely fun. The last game I played the only number I did not have was three. So every dice roll was either a three or, when the AI was rolling, a seven, so the AI could take cards from me. Don’t rig the dice to compensate for your inability to properly program competitive AI.

Great adaptation

Dookarocha

I like this adaptation. It is fun and true to the board game.

I win more than I lose.

Tigerphantom

I play against two of their bots. At the beginning they only use the 7’s and the robber against each other. You have better chances of winning if you both start as player 1 and set the game dice to stack 5. It also helps to choose opponents with low skills! I have experienced no glitches or IT issues at all. Try it this way and see.

Catan HD Reviews – Page 6